Thursday, May 20, 2010

Pressure

I feel so much pressure today. Yesterday afternoon I attended an parent-information meeting at the school. In a few weeks, the 5th graders are going to have some lessons on puberty and adolescence. And a lesson on HIV/AIDS.

I remember in 5th grade having the film telling us how our bodies work. Girls were in one classroom, boys in the other. But I don't remember seeing the boy film. At DD's school they will see both the boy and girl films. Does my 10-year-old really need to know what a "nocturnal emission" is right now? (In the film they also mention the more common name for it).

Then in the HIV/AIDS lesson, not only will they teach about safe sex but they will demonstrate the proper use of a condom. Um, excuse me, my 10-year-old doesn't need to know that yet.

I know lots of parents who have "the talk" with their kids at 8-years-old, or within the next few years. Our approach with DD has been a little bit of info at a time. Instead of sitting down and giving all the information at once, we've taken it step-by-step so she can absorb what we've told her at that time.

But now I feel like we have to do a crash course because of the presentations coming up at school. We can opt her out of the lessons--she would go to the library and work on other health-related issues. But you know her friends will be talking about it.

I'm just not ready. I hate feeling this kind of pressure. I understand there are kids in her class going through puberty right now--but couldn't the sex ed and HIV/AIDS info come next year or in 7th grade?

Maybe I'm just naive. Maybe it is because she is my first child and we haven't been through it before.

Any advice/opinions you can share with me would be awesome!

9 comments:

Lillian Child said...

Oh my dear ... I know I'm from a few generations removed, but this just is not the age for SO MUCH knowledge. I emphatically believe that this should NOT be a co-ed educational program - at this age information about their own gender seems to be all they should need to worry about. I think if I had been "exposed" to the male parts at such a young age it would have been very uncomfortable. I think junior high or 7th+ grade is more than soon enough for the HIV-Aids and condom application chat. But not 5th grade - let them be children for just a while longer!

SusGus said...

I think this is a little early for the HIV, etc. discussion too. Did the school share any info about why this is appropriate now?

good luck...

EmmaJ said...

I think 10 is way too young too, but I also understand why they are doing it at 10. I don't know if this is possible, but what if you watched it first, so you would be able to answer her questions specifically based on what she watched. I remember when I saw the girl video, most of it didn't sink in until those things started happening to me.
Good luck with whatever you decide.

Melanie said...

Susannah--It is a state mandate for the students to be educated in these areas by 5th grade.

Emma--I saw the videos and would be fine with her watching the girl one. I don't think it is necessary for her to see the boy one though.

Lisa in Texas said...

Melanie, Wow, they do stuff a lot different in different areas. My son was in 5th grade last year, they separated into boy/girl rooms and each watched the video appropriate for their gender. They did NOT talk about HIV/AIDS..although I have told my son what it is and how you get it as there are a few ways of transmission...if it was my son I would NOT want him to watch both movies OR learn a huge in depth thing about HIV/AIDs...especially for a girl to see the boy film I would not want that. My son would have DIED if he had to watch the girl movie! LOL! We live in a VERY conservative state, for which most times I am grateful, as they do not push stuff such as this on a 5th grader...oh and it had NO talk of condoms in his film. No mothers attended either, the boys all asked their dads or other male to attend with them, my son was too embarrased for me to go, so he invited my BIL. Although I saw the film ahead of time. Good luck with this hard decision.

Lisa in Texas said...

Oh, just another thing I thought of...a lot of kids were not allowed to go by their parents to the videos and according to my son, the kids DID NOT discuss it, they were all to embarrassed....so it may be the age. Plus the teachers told them that they should ask an adult any questions not another kid. We have a neighbor boy that did not go per his parents not wanting him to and the MOm never mentioned other kids telling him about it as an issue, and I am sure she would have mentioned it if it had been an issue.

Anonymous said...

Wow. It's way too young. Good luck with your decision! I'm sure it's a tough one.

Deana said...

I caught only one Dr Phil show in the past year. It happened to be about kids & sex. Accd'g to him... it starts a LOT younger than it all did when we were that age. So, I guess if it, sadly, is starting for some kids in middle school, than they feel the need to tackle these issues in 5th grade. He said you have to start the convo at home at a very early age. So, that day, I got out a book about where babies come from & matter-of-factly brought up sex. Even though she's 8 (almost 9 now), I want her to feel like we can talk about these things without embarrassment. My own mom surely did not do that with me.

I'm really not sure what info will be given when Bryn's in 5th grade, & while I'd be sad that HIV is part of the discussion at such a young age, I'd much rather she learn it from me & the school than to learn about it all on the bus & among "friends." Somehow the tales always grow taller on down the line... ;-)

Good luck, Melanie! Sending hugs...

Lynette Jacobs said...

I am one of the "old fashioned" ones that believe that this should be taught on a "need to know" basis as they develop....AT HOME! I hate it that schools are instrumental in stealing our children's innocence.